Portrait of business colleagues holding each other and laughingOur thanks to freelance writer Stephen Jeske for this guest post.

Obtaining some solid book reviews involves “learning the art of asking.” You’ve got to know the right people to ask and the best way to approach them. According to this New York Times article, up to 600,000 self-published books could hit the market in 2015. That works out to one book for every 523 Americans, resulting in more competition in an already competitive field.

Your blog readers may be your best source of reviews.

Ask the Right People

While the chance of getting onto The New York Times Book Review is miniscule at best, realistic alternatives exist for budding authors. Perhaps the best tactic is to start with your immediate circle of influence.

It’s a strategy that worked well for Tim Ferriss, the popular self-help guru. He gave away a thousand advance copies of “The 4-Hour Body” leading up to its publication. Where did these all go? They were primarily sent to friends and associates who helped or volunteered their assistance. On the day of publication, Ferriss asked recipients to write a short review on Amazon. Many complied with the request, and he received about 200 positive reviews within the first week.

While Ferriss already had a large audience, size is actually irrelevant. People who know you are more likely to provide a review. Social media, forums, and your own blog are all excellent methods of building an audience far in advance of any book release.

Maintaining your own blog also provides the opportunity to network with other influential bloggers in your field. Although these people seem to be busier than ever, you’ll gain their attention by following their blogs, posting insightful comments, retweeting a review of their book, and doing anything else that can help them. When the time is right, and you’ve shown how you can help them, then you can ask for a review.

Reviewing other authors’ books is another method to get more reviews for your own book. First off, everyone loves peer reviews since they are considered to be more honest. Second, it’s easier to get a review from another author if you’ve already reviewed their publication. It’s kind of a “you scratch my back and I’ll scratch yours” approach, but it works. Just remember to let an author know when you’ve reviewed their book.

Ask the Right Way

Getting solid book reviews demands a certain method in approaching reviewers. Magdalena Ball of The Compulsive Reader provides some useful insight in this OutboxOnline.com post.

First point: Many feel that sending an unrequested book to a reviewer is unprofessional and a waste of your time and money. Send a query letter in advance by email, following the reviewer’s guidelines. Based on your query letter, the reviewer will let you know if they are interested. Take your time constructing your query letter so that it’s concise, enticing, and grammatically correct.

At this stage of the game, your book is being judged by your query letter, so put forth your best effort. Make sure to follow up politely and professionally if you haven’t heard back within a suitable time frame. If you have anything to build on your story, like an award, include it in your follow up email to help build excitement.

Ask Enough People

While it would be wonderful if everyone who received a complimentary book actually reviewed it, reality shows otherwise. In Tim Ferriss’s case, the initial response rate from his giveaway was 20 percent. Even if you restricted complimentary copies to only those people who agreed in advance to review it, it’s unlikely that you’ll receive a 100 percent response rate. Despite your best efforts, people will forget, change priorities, or have any other number of excuses. It still is a numbers game.

Plug Your NoseThey say your book stinks? It doesn’t matter.

Any Publicity May Be Better Than None

Although unknown authors have a hard time getting reviews, there is a bright side. Bad publicity may actually help sales of lesser known authors, according to this The Stanford Daily article.

You’ll have to judge for yourself whether any publicity is good publicity, but either way, it’s a sound idea to monitor the online conversation surrounding your book. The simplest way is to use Google Alerts to set up an alert based on your book title, or use one of the other free or premium services like Reputation.com. This way you’ll get notified every time your book is mentioned online. You can change the notification frequency if you find you’re getting too many alerts, which will inevitably happen if your book becomes popular. It’s a good idea to connect with anyone that mentions your book and thank them for the feedback.

Make no mistake: Getting your book reviewed requires an enormous amount of time and dedication. Start first with your circle of influence, especially those who read your blog. Use well written query letters before sending any material, and follow up in a courteous manner.

Stephen-JeskeStephen Jeske is an avid outdoor enthusiast with a passion for coffee. He frequently writes about personal branding and reputation.

 

7 thoughts on “How to Solicit Book Reviews—and Get Results

  • February 20, 2013 at 8:30 pm
    Permalink

    This article says: ‘On the day of publication, Ferriss asked recipients to write a short review on Amazon. Many complied with the request, and he received about 200 positive reviews within the first week.”
    I believe I’m right in pointing out that to review a book on Amazon, one has to have bought the book from Amazon.

    • February 21, 2013 at 1:49 am
      Permalink

      Not exactly. Amazon’s rule regarding who can submit a review states: “Anyone who has purchased items from Amazon.com.” Meaning, you have to be an Amazon customer with a login. I’ve left plenty of reviews on Amazon and other sites for books I’ve purchased direct from authors at book signings and at book fests. Hope that helps!

  • February 19, 2013 at 3:33 pm
    Permalink

    Word of caution on the give-away for reviews on Goodreads? Just read a long thread from some authors who gave away books for review On GR only to get no review and seen their books listed for sale on Craig’s List and E-Bay. Not sure how to keep track of this, but suggest some kind of verification. But a good review from an influential reviewer has a lot of power.

  • February 19, 2013 at 1:52 pm
    Permalink

    I’m so glad to see an article about getting book reviews. It is a very important part of the book publishing process.

    As a reviewer for the New York Journal of Books (NYJB) and panel member of the National Book Critics Circle, I’d like to add some thoughts and observations to this well researched piece.

    While a lot of positive reviews are nice, the quality and origin is seriously taken into account. It is all to well known that 100 positive reviews on Amazon is suspect. As well, the merit of the book review Website (non-professional, peer review) is yet another consideration for the reader looking for honest observation.

    We want everyone to love our books, but the professional writer will accept that not everyone thinks our prose, research, point of view, etc. is excellent. Seeking only positive reviews from friends, family like-minded peers is limiting at best and dilutes the level of credibility.

    At NYJB we eagerly look for small press and emerging writers to review. However, our rules are strictly enforced: We cannot review a book where we know the author. This is ethically paramount. In order to take a review seriously, and maintain our high standards At NYJB the public, publishers, editors and everyone in the book business, as well as readers, knows our reviews are objective. As such, we do not write reviews on Amazon or other non-professional review Web sites.

    From the personal perspective, while I may not get a triple A book review, I will get a review from someone who has the professional credentials to analyze my work.

    • February 19, 2013 at 2:42 pm
      Permalink

      Brava, Geri – thanks for bringing up the integrity piece of this puzzle – if readers can’t trust the sources, the value of book reviews will no doubt be diluted… Shari

  • February 19, 2013 at 9:43 am
    Permalink

    Thanks for the advice. This is where I’m struggling with my newest book. Great info!

  • February 19, 2013 at 9:36 am
    Permalink

    Great article …so helpful for all the newbies out there!
    The key is never to give up even on those days when you feel so discouraged. Thanks again

Comments are closed.