Thanks to blogger Carl Shaw for this guest post.
I like to use social media and use Twitter, Facebook, YouTube and Instagram every day even if it’s just to check out how my posts are being viewed or what everyone else is posting. There have been some internet stories recently about how some businesses are manipulating the statistics that many people use to judge how popular something is. Yes we are “sheeple” and I will admit that I like to follow the crowd, re-tweeting popular things that I see and liking or following posts or accounts that say something profound or make me chuckle.
It is true that by adding to an author’s amount of followers, re-tweets or likes it makes it more likely that others will also view a post or account so I can definitely see why it is done. I get a little thrill when someone likes a post I make or follows me so I can imagine how it would be to have hundreds or even thousands suddenly jumping onto my account making me seem much more popular.
The Fake Social Media Account Phenomenon
There seems to be two ways that the fake accounts or at least the accounts that I have been able to find that look fake, are made. One method is by having teams of overseas workers making accounts manually. This can be time consuming and has led many social media companies to look for accounts created from the same IP addresses in a short amount of time. The second method is using a bot to create accounts in an automated process. This can be seen by having blank account information and sometimes even uses numbers in the account names that can be very easy to spot.
In an effort to avoid these obvious problems which are easy to spot and make them ineffective there are a new generation of providers that have moved away from generating huge numbers of low quality accounts that have limited use and instead are concentrating on creating quality accounts that look and behave like a real account. This has made them undetectable because they use proper names and have a history of use that is ongoing.
While there are still many offerings for the easily detected and obviously fake followers how can we even be sure how widespread the use of these new generation fake accounts are? They are not being detected and reported and I have looked extensively on the internet and have not seen anything that talks about it. It seems that it is impossible to pick real from illusion.
Price and Effectiveness
There has been a large drop over the last few years as more businesses set up and try to make money by selling fake social media likes, followers and re-tweets across the different platforms. The area that seems to be attracting the most attention lately is Twitter. There are literally hundreds of businesses that advertise how you can buy twitter followers for prices that are dirt cheap.
The trend is that the more you buy the cheaper it is and easily detected followers from lower quality providers are not any cheaper than the higher quality followers on offer. You can expect to pay anywhere from a few pence or cents each to fractions of a penny or a cent each for large numbers of followers.
There does not seem to be more than anecdotal evidence about how effective or ineffective buying followers can be. What has been seen is the negative publicity that has been generated by the use of fake social media statistic building. It seems pretty clear that if you do decide to use this sort of a service then make sure it is not going to flood you with bad followers that are obviously fake.
Social Media Companies Do Not Seem Interested In Fakes
It seems strange to me that these media behemoths have not stamped this practice out. It has been going on publicly for many years. There have been moves in recent times against accounts that are obviously fake but even they are patchy at best and do not seem to be a priority.
While there have been a few notable users caught out there has not been an outcry from users, businesses that use social media or social media companies themselves. So what is the big deal then? It is hard to say, I mean we all want everything to be fair and even but it isn’t. Money gets you bigger, better and faster in all things in life so that may explain why this just isn’t important to some people. If they want to spend some money improving their followers in the hope of getting a bigger audience then let them. If they have nothing interesting to say then in the end it is not going to make any difference and if they do have something interesting then maybe it’s even a good idea.
What I Think
If you want to try this then be smart. It is obvious that using bad accounts are not worth the effort so you need to find a business that has a track record of providing fake followers from good accounts that will pass any inspection. Having the ability to ensure that these followers stay active in the long term is also a big plus. So is you want to cheat a little, yes it is cheating, then do it the right way that will not blow up in your face. I strongly suspect that this is happening a lot more than many people may think so join the rest of them and do it the right way so no one but you knows.
Some of the information used in the article was taken from the followersboosts.com website. They use a similar system to that described above and is undetectable.
So, what do you think? Is it worth a few bucks to “make the party look bigger” on your author website?
Firstly, great article. I found it really interesting and must admit I have considered this debate myself.
I published my first children’s book in June this year and I had never used Twitter before. I only started because I felt I had to in order to promote my book. And for the first month I had about 20 followers.
Then I did something which caused my following to grow from 20 to over 800 in a few months. No buying followers, no advertising. I simply asked people for their feedback in regard to my book and gave them a link where they could read it for free (my website). Simple. And I continued to do this on a daily basis.
My book is illustrated by a 7yo boy with Autism and I wrote it to encourage every child to believe in themselves and reach for their dreams. So I know I have a wonderful message to share with people. By focusing on that and asking others to engage with me I started getting 25-30 followers per day.
The thing that buying followers does not do for a new author is teach them how to engage with potential readers. Unless you’re a marketing guru you need to learn this through trial and error. This is why I would encourage new authors (like myself) not to go down this path. You want to build a foundation that is strong and will provide genuine connections with potential readers. You’ll be amazed at the response and support you will receive if you put in the hard yards and take the time to do this.
Twitter is now my favorite form of social media and I have made some of the best connections through this incredible channel. You can connect with me @JEd_Au. I’d love to hear from you 🙂
Justine Edward (author of ‘Shine’)
Outstanding advice, Justine and you’re very right – you’re not learning to engage with potential readers if you’re just buying ’em!
I can see where this might come in handy if a blogger is trying to build a platform for a career in writing. Although, it could have drawbacks in the sense that part of the followers won’t be real, so can’t buy the long-awaited book. It has its pros and cons, like anything else..
As great as it may sound using these methods to get more traffic will one back fire when you least expected. As a child I was told cheaters never prosper. The best way to get followers is to join blog groups. You will find you get your regulars. In fact I just put you on my list as I found you on Jacquie’s blog. I have only doing this for 6 months and I am pleased with the response.
Wow. Call me a real neophyte. Call me a purist. I can’t think of a single reason to create fake followers. I would rather know within my soul that I earned followers by the words I write and take my lumps in public perception. Certainly this practice would come back to haunt us more than a Halloween mask!
Agree, but sometimes it gives folks a leg up while they’re trying to build a fan base. So long as they’re working hard to build the base, the real followers will win out.
Thanks. I was not tempted to use purchasing programs to buy followers, but getting them the “real” way is a mystery to me, to some extent,especially with the absurd metrics Twitter puts on the ratio between the number of my followers : those I have followed. It’s good to know I was right. Now, I’d like to be popular!
And that’s one reason to buy Twitter followers, so you can follow more folks, who can then follow you back, and get around the Twitter metrics. In other words, if you’ve hit your 2,000 max following/followers and you buy 500, that lets you follow 500 more who have the potential to then see you and follow back…
Just skip the buying the fake followers and head straight for the fake book purchasers. It’s a more expensive option, sure, but will quickly get your book on the best seller list. Until, that is, everyone finds out you are a fake.
I don’t think posts like this do anyone a service.
Funny! But again, it depends on the author and the circumstance – whether to be able to follow more folks who can then follow back, or to “make the party look bigger” and thus entice real fans in for a drink and chips 🙂 It is important to know the practice exists and how businesses are using it to their advantage.